The Best Sapphic Fantasy and Witchy Romance Books
Some love stories need a little magic. Whether it's demons and deals, witches and festivals, or fate intervening in the most supernatural ways, these are the best sapphic fantasy and witchy romance books for readers who want their happily ever after with a side of the otherworldly.
The Devil She Knows — Alexandria Bellefleur
She made a deal with a demon to get her ex back. She did not expect the demon to be this charming. Alexandria Bellefleur brings her signature slow burn and sharp wit to a paranormal sapphic romance set in New York City. Funny, steamy, and unexpectedly tender.
This Spells Disaster — Tori Anne Martin
A witches festival. A fake relationship. Very real chemistry. Set in New England with all the autumn atmosphere you could want, this USA Today bestseller is the witchy fake dating sapphic romance that BookTok has been obsessing over. Perfect for cozy season reading.
Improbable Magic for Cynical Witches — Kate Scelsa
A grieving girl arrives in Salem and falls into a coven of witches, a tarot deck full of secrets, and a love she never saw coming. Note: this is YA, not adult romance. But the sapphic heart is enormous and the Salem setting is absolutely perfect for this kind of story.
Even Though I Knew the End — C.L. Polk
A sapphic noir fantasy novella set in 1930s Chicago. A demon-hunter who sold her soul makes a final bargain to solve one last case and runs into the woman she loves. Atmospheric, romantic, and devastating in the best way. Lambda Literary Award winner. If you read one sapphic fantasy novella this year, make it this one.
One Last Stop — Casey McQuiston
August moves to New York and meets the most beautiful woman she has ever seen on the subway, who has been trapped in the 1970s for decades. Part magical realism, part love story, part celebration of queer community. Casey McQuiston writes the best found family sapphic romance, and this is their finest.
Want more curated reading lists? Browse all our lists or filter by trope on Find a Book.